Comfyui vs automatic1111 review

 

Both are also relatively easy to install. A basic interface that would act/look like Automatic1111 interface, and a "backend" on nodes. The number of mentions indicates the total number of ComfyUI. . Similarly, in the 1024 by 1024 test, the average time was 21. Check out ComfyUI for a much more advanced and open source version of this. A lot of people are just discovering this technology, and want to show off what they created. glide-text2im-colab - Colab notebook for openai/glide-text2im. 5. I vaguely remember Comfy himself mentioning some fix (not sure if it was to this problem though), so have you tried to run update script recently? If not, that might be the solution. The ideal solution would be to have a two-level system. EDIT : Extension has been renamed to Cozy-Nest. Comfy UI: the Perfect Automatic1111 WebUI Alternative Comfy UI versus Automatic1111 WebUI: A Quick Comparison ComfyUI-to-Python-Extension - A powerful tool that translates ComfyUI workflows into executable Python code. 🏆. Maybe I am doing it wrong, but ComfyUI inpainting is a bit awkward to use. With a pre-loaded balance of at least $10 in your account, you can spin up an instance of Automatic1111 with several For image generation I don't have immediate plans, but checkout these projects for local image generation. Learn more or download it from its GitHub page. ComfyUI has you covered for creating dynamic and interactive workflows. As far as that's concerned, it looks like it's baked in. Q: Are you using comfyui to sample images? No. And because of this I had always face memory issues with Automatic1111. Comfyui wasn't designed for Animatediff and long batch, yet it's the best platform for it thanks to the community. Load Image & MaskEditor. Reload to refresh your session. Automatic1111 for multiple workflows and extensions. And the new interface is also an improvement as it's cleaner and tighter. It is not a problem in the seed, because I tried different seeds. And above all, BE NICE. Most of them already are if you are using the DEV branch by the way. You can construct an image generation workflow by chaining different blocks (called nodes) together. 16 seconds, a mere two seconds faster than Invoke AI and considerably faster than Automatic 1111. Some commonly used blocks are Loading a Checkpoint Model, entering a prompt, specifying a sampler, etc. I'm not doing anything crazy or complicated, just messing around with simple prompts to try and understand the differences. Provides a browser UI for generating images from text prompts and images. And boy I was blown away by the fact that how well it uses a GPU. After you get the logic of diffusion you start creating your own workflows. sd-webui-comfyui is an extension for A1111 webui that embeds ComfyUI workflows in different sections of the normal pipeline of the webui. I use Stable Diffusion family models for innovative art products. ComfyUI-Image-Selector - Select one or some of images from a batch gpt-j-fine-tuning-example - Fine-tuning 6-Billion GPT-J (& other models) with LoRA and 8-bit compression Sep 27, 2023 · Follow these steps to use a LyCORIS model in AUTOMATIC1111. The main difference between ComfyUI and Automatic1111 is that Comfy uses a non-destructive workflow. ComfyUI is also trivial to extend with custom nodes. #config for a1111 ui. This can have bigger or smaller differences depending on the LoRA itself. Comfyui is much better suited for studio use than other GUIs available now. Mar 20, 2024 · ComfyUI is a node-based GUI for Stable Diffusion. Jan 26, 2024 · In this blog article, we will review the main difference between ComfyUI vs Automatic1111. Just give it a try. openpose-editor - Openpose Editor for AUTOMATIC1111's stable-diffusion-webui. I have read that ComfyUI overall provides more performance benefits especially in ram/vram usage compared to automatic1111. Eyes are improved and composition is also improved. r/StableDiffusion. Compatible with Civitai & Prompthero geninfo auto-detection. 4 mins read. When I do the same in Automatic1111, I get completely different people and different compositions for every image. Discussion. I'm currently using Automatic on a MAC OS, but having numerous problems. comfyUI takes 1:30s, auto1111 is taking over 2:05s so, wanted to ask, is it just me or others are facing the same performance issues with auto1111? [FYI Aug 19, 2023 · Why switch from automatic1111 to Comfy. CLIP set last layer inverts this, where -1 is the last layer. We know A1111 was using xformers, but weren't told, as far as i noticed, what ComfyUI was using. to the corresponding Comfy folders, as discussed in ComfyUI manual installation. For example, in Automatic1111 after spending a lot of ComfyUI: An extremely powerful Stable Diffusion GUI with a graph/nodes interface for advanced users that gives you precise control over the diffusion process without coding anything now supports ControlNets Jan 26, 2023 · ComfyUI has a complete set of node UI and usage logic, so it does not need to be integrated with WebUI. AUTOMATIC1111 has long been regarded as the default choice for Stable Diffusion GUI. I get around 1. It does things a little differently by focusing on skin tones and fine details. ComfyUI vs Automatic1111 สอบถามครับ สองตัวนี้ต่างกันยังไง เราควร เลือกใช้ยังไงดีครับ Stable Diffusion Thailand | ComfyUI vs Automatic1111 I will be getting an intel i5 12th generation, NVIDIA GTX 4060 8GB laptop, 16 GB RAM ( LPDDR4 ), for AI related work. Nov 26, 2023 · Automatic1111からComfyUIへの移行で手間取った点を備忘録として残します。少しずつ移行して行く予定なのでその都度更新します。 ComfyUIのダウンロードや基本的なGUIの説明は以下サイトが参考になります。 【Stable Diffusion】ComfyUIとは？インストール方法と基本的な使い方について | イクログ (ikuriblog Moving on to Comfy UI, we found that it offered even faster performance than Invoke AI. Lately I've been spending a lot more time in ComfyUI because after getting over the hurdle of working with nodes I'm enjoying the ability to set up repeatable workflows, and also using workflows that others have created. Initial Setup Download and extract the ComfyUI software package from GitHub to your desired directory. yaml file within the ComfyUI directory. Why ComfyUI and Automatic1111 can and should coexist. To be begin with I have only 4GB Vram and by todays standards it's considered potato. ComfyUI Is pretty Dope To be Honest. It ventures into the realm of creative writing and image generation, offering a Dec 19, 2023 · Step 4: Start ComfyUI. comfyui vs automatic1111 vs fooocus : r/StableDiffusion. This project is non-commercial and for the community, not for promotion of any models or products. Q: Are you using comfyui’s text encoder to encode prompt? No. You have to draw a mask, save the image with the mask, then upload to the UI again to inpaint. Nov 12, 2023 · これは原則として使えない、と思う。 理由は簡単で、A1111向けに開発されていたから。 一部は移植されているかも。 A1111は標準機能であったExtentionの検索はでComfyUIではデフォルトでは搭載されていないので、ComfyUI Managerというのを入れないといけない。 Jul 27, 2023 · You signed in with another tab or window. While the shift to ComfyUI requires learning new conventions, the great community and documentation give you a helping hand with great guides and tutorials. Yes. On my 12GB 3060, A1111 can't generate a single SDXL 1024x1024 image without using RAM for VRAM at some point near the end of generation, even with --medvram set. Stars - the number of stars that a project has on May 16, 2024 · ComfyUI에서 ControlNet 마스터하기 에 대한 자세한 튜토리얼을 확인해 보세요! 📚 단계별 가이드와 영감을 주는 예제로 가득 차 있어 ControlNet 전문가가 될 수 있습니다. 1) in A1111. ComfyUI - great for complex workflows. I also just learned of something called TensorRT, that might give around another %50 speed boost, which Jul 31, 2023 · After launching ComfyUI and opening it in the browser window, the easiest way to start with the first workflow is by using an example image. Dec 16, 2023. VFX artists are also typically very familiar with node based UIs as they are very common in that space. g. punter1965. The most powerful and modular stable diffusion GUI, api and backend with a graph/nodes interface. You can even overlap regions to ensure they blend together properly. The Clip model is part of what you (if you want to) feed into the LoRA loader and will also have, in simple terms, trained weights applied to it to subtly adjust the output. Just Started using ComfyUI when I got to know about it in the recent SD XL news. json workflow file you downloaded in the previous step. ComfyUI vs Automatic1111 (A1111) ComfyUI and Automatic1111 (sometimes also called A1111 or stable-diffusion-webui) are the two most popular Stable Diffusion UIs, and they both have their strengths and weaknesses. Dec 5, 2023 · This tool opens up a world of creative possibilities with Stable Diffusion. bat and ComfyUI will automatically open in your web browser. Pros of Using ComfyUI: since you already have experience with a1111 go for it its really fun. If you have another Stable Diffusion UI you might be able to reuse the dependencies. Laptop: Acer predator Helios Neo 16. It will load the nodes as it needs to be. Hopefully, some of the most important extensions such as Adetailer will be ported to ComfyUI. Only models that are compatible with the selected Checkpoint model will show up. comfyui uses its own text encoder. Tips for Optimizing ComfyUI Workflows: Node Management: Keep your workflow clean by grouping related nodes and labeling them clearly. We tested different sampling methods and steps to analyze their impact on image generation. Within the Load Image node in ComfyUI, there is the MaskEditor option: This provides you with a basic brush that you can use to mask/select the portions of the image Hello! Looking to dive into animatediff and am looking to learn from the mistakes of those that walked the path before me🫡🙌🫡🙌🫡🙌🫡🙌 Are people using… Feb 10, 2024 · We also use comfyui’s many optimization methods to improve the webui inference, like more compact attention codes, etc. stable-diffusion-ui - Easiest 1-click way to install and use Stable Diffusion on your computer. The video was pretty interesting, beyond the A1111 vs. In general, you can see it as an extra knob to turn for fine adjustments, but in a lot of LoRAs I Apr 30, 2023 · The automatic1111 extension for comfyUI is broken badly for me but it would be ideal to be able to run comfyUI and import the modules to a more polished platform if not more stable, then people could introduce ideas that could be incorporated instantly by anyone to a linked library with all dependencies preinstalled or at least linked to good And if you're seeking the alternative Stable Diffusion UI to replace the Automatic1111 UI, let me introduce you to: Comfy UI - a modular and powerful GUI (Graphical User Interface) for Stable Diffusion. Nix0npolska. So if you load a Lora on "A1111" level, it would rewire the nodes on the "backend" level (where you can setup and change the subtle things in case needed). You can share your models and loras and TIs between different WebUI. May 7, 2024 · For straightforward image generation, ThinkDiffusion works exceptionally well. ComfyUI has a GPL license [1] while this project uses this [2]. 61 GB; Best Avg Cold Start Time: 40. Nov 28, 2023 · Size without models: 3. Our backend is Automatic1111 and we use Automatic1111 to sample images. Click the LyCORIS Welcome to r/gaminglaptops, the hub for gaming laptop enthusiasts. (by comfyanonymous) Get real-time insights from all types of time series data with InfluxDB. the A1111 took forever to generate an image without refiner the UI was very laggy I did remove all the extensions but nothing really change so the image always stocked on 98% I don't know why. My guess -- and it's purely a guess -- is that ComfyUI wasn't using the best cross-attention optimization. This allows to create ComfyUI nodes that interact directly with some parts of the webui's normal pipeline. Next: Advanced Implementation of Stable Diffusion and other Diffusion-based generative image models . Ingest, query, and analyze billions of data points in real-time with unbounded cardinality. If something is really good, Automatic1111 will review it and bring it to users. ·. ComfyUI will help you learn what's going on underneath if you take the time to learn and build your own workflows. 0 on my RTX 2060 laptop 6gb vram on both A1111 and ComfyUI. Please share your tips, tricks, and workflows for using this software to create your AI art. ComfyUI Manager 🛠️. T ComfyUI. One of the first features that users look for when transitioning from Automatic1111 WebUI to ComfyUI is the ComfyUI-Custom-Scripts - Enhancements & experiments for ComfyUI, mostly focusing on UI features kohya_ss_google_colab - A kohya_ss port for google colab smooth-infinite-zoom - User friendly infinite zoom video generation tool in Colab (based on Stable Diffusion) what comfyui devs say and what people do with customs nodes are different thing. I think the noise is also generated differently where A1111 uses GPU by default and ComfyUI uses CPU by default, which makes using the same seed give different results. There are different ways of interpreting the up or down-weighting of words in prompts. В чем его Best: ComfyUI, but it has a steep learning curve. Stay tuned for more detailed insights into making the most of Comfy UI. Click the Extra Networks button under the Generate button. 7s on RTX 3090 Ti; While designed and built as a user interface for running stable diffusion on your own PC, Automatic1111 is also a very popular inference backend for many commercial SD-powered applications. The number of mentions indicates the total number of Yes. This results in markedly different behavior at higher weighting. So I gave up and tried the normal xformers image generation. There are some custom nodes/extensions to make generation between the two interfaces compatible. Please suggest which GUI will be best for my usecase. Reply. Go to this link (Examples section of ComfyUI GitHub), download the image from there, and drag it into the WebUI. As new models, refiners, and other ComfyUI. 1. Just pick one directory and put a proper path to load your models in both A1111 and ComfyUI. In a way it compares to Apple devices (it just works) vs Linux (it needs to work exactly in some way). And the clever tricks discovered from using ComfyUI will be ported to the Automatic1111-WebUI. A lot of people borrow a master workflow someone else build, but initially, to learn, I recommend always building your workflows depending on the what you're trying to do. 9. The concept is based on training big models with large amounts of data, resulting in the ability to generate high-quality images from text. For example I enjoy mixing different models and see the results, with comfy I just select few models then let comfy generate random weights for each merging and see the results. 1) in ComfyUI is much stronger than (word:1. Am I cruising for a bruising using Automatic1111's? HLKY vs AUTOMATIC1111 in terms of results. Automatic1111 is significantly faster though. Through our analysis, we observed variations in image quality, processing speed, and overall performance. StabilityMatrix is a launcher that preconfigures your UIs directories, either with arguments or symlinks, to share Welcome to the unofficial ComfyUI subreddit. Belittling their efforts will get you banned. Reply reply. yaml and ComfyUI will load it. This is a project that uses a custom license with less rights provided than the ComfyUI project it self-describes as improving. Then moved onto AUTOMATIC1111 because of all the features it had. It's still 30 seconds slower than comfyUI with the same 1366x768 resolution and 105 steps. Install the ComfyUI dependencies. 13 GB; Size with models: 5. 47 seconds, which was around 15 seconds faster May 29, 2023 · ComfyUI is a powerful and versatile tool for data scientists, researchers, and developers. Launch ComfyUI by running python main. • 6 mo. Its integration with stability. Run ComfyUI under the Python venv of Automatic1111. ComfyUI-Manager is an extension designed to enhance the usability of ComfyUI. •. Here is an example: k_lms cfg_scale: 15 steps: 60 height: 512 seed: 3993080460. It is said to be very easy and afaik can "grow" with you as you learn more skills. Beta Was this translation helpful? /r/StableDiffusion is back open after the protest of Reddit killing open API access, which will bankrupt app developers, hamper moderation, and exclude blind users from the site. Clmntgbrl. With its intuitive node interface, compatibility with various models and checkpoints, and easy workflow management, ComfyUI streamlines the process of creating complex workflows. 0, an open model representing the next step in the evolution of text-to-image generation models. I had plenty of CUDA out of memory errors in a1111 with my 6GB GXT1660. Try both and then use the one you like better. If you just want to make images and see results quickly then Automatic1111 is the best choice. Yet, with the emergence of ComfyUI, users find themselves at a crossroad, questioning the better choice. I honestly don't know where I stand since this is a legal document using non-standard phrasing to describe how the rights around the source code. Fooocus vs ComfyUI vs AUTOMATIC1111 ? I am an absolute beginner in photo editing I have used some basic tools in photoshop and generative AI, I don't know which GUI to use, I will be mostly using inpaint, outpaint and text generation. 0 A1111 vs ComfyUI 6gb vram, thoughts. ddetailer. The more complex the workflows get (e. A1111 for instance simply scales the associated vector by the prompt weight, while ComfyUI by default calculates a travel direction from the prompt and an empty prompt. Here’s a thorough comparison to aid in your decision-making. I did the 2nd one to share all the PyTorch and Xformer library installs that Automatic1111 has done. Also the exact same position of the body. However, if you are starting from scratch, it is usually easier to begin with Automatic1111. Feb 17, 2024 · ComfyUI Starting Guide 1: Basic Introduction to ComfyUI and Comparison with Automatic1111. py; Note: Remember to add your models, VAE, LoRAs etc. Automatic1111 is great, but the one that impressed me, in doing things that Automatic1111 can't, is ComfyUI. Automatic1111 vs comfyui for Mac OS Silicon. I'm very curious if anyone has used it and gotten some impressive results. ComfyUI is when you really need to get something very specific done, and disassemble the visual interface to get to the machinery. Weighing Your Options Both great, but with comfy you have way more flexibility, you can do probably anything just need to figure out how. SDXL 1. It's fully c Jul 19, 2023 · AUTO1111 and ComfyUI unite with the sd-webui-comfyui extension from ModelSurge. Furthermore, this extension provides a hub feature and convenience functions to access a wide range of information within ComfyUI. Stable diffusion is a model used for text-to-image generation. Backup Regularly: Always save your workflows. Vondy is an impressive AI platform that goes beyond the typical text generation tools. Make sure you have selected a compatible checkpoint model. You signed out in another tab or window. Click the Load button and select the . ComfyUI ComfyUI provides an alternative interface for managing and interacting with image generation models. Easiest: Check Fooocus. On a small scale, you have to professionalize ComfyUI’s development. CUI can do a batch of 4 and stay within the 12 GB. It's more a question of taste. Targren. RunDiffusion Photo - Crystal. ai and compatibility across various hardware setups make it a valuable asset for creators looking to explore the depths of AI-driven art. In this article, we explored the stability and performance of two UI versions: stable diffusion automatic 1111 and config UI. you are comparing it/s with s/it, that's very confusing. Don't know if inpainting works with SDXL, but ComfyUI inpainting works with SD 1. Fooocus / Fooocus-MRE / RuinedFooocus - quick image generation, and simple and easy to use GUI (Based on the Comfy backend). Easiest-ish: A1111 might not be absolutely easiest UI out there, but that's offset by the fact that it has by far the most users - tutorials and help is easy to find. The workflow is different, but the results are identical. В этом видео разберемся что такое ComfyUi и зачем он нужен. Below are the setup instructions to get ComfyUI running alongside your other tools. Workflows are much more easily reproducible and versionable. 5 and 2. A non-destructive workflow is a workflow where you can reverse and redo something earlier in the pipeline after working on later steps. Also my configuration. Discover discussions, news, reviews, and advice on finding the perfect gaming laptop. Is it the case that Automatic is not getting much maintenance these days? ЧАСТЬ 1 Начинаем новую серию видео про ComfyUI. When comparing sd-webui-controlnet and ComfyUI you can also consider the following projects: stable-diffusion-webui - Stable Diffusion web UI. #all you have to do is change the base When comparing ComfyUI and sd-webui-controlnet you can also consider the following projects: stable-diffusion-webui - Stable Diffusion web UI. The workshop that Olivio Sarikas shared on the openart website really helped me to understand how to use it. ComfyUI breaks down a workflow into rearrangeable elements so you can easily make your own. Uses less VRAM than A1111. Please keep posted images SFW. ago. When I generate an image with the prompt "attractive woman" in ComfyUI, I get the exact same face for every image I create. Fooocus is also very nice to use. This can of course also be good, because you are forced to engage more with the subject matter and learn more. Lacks the extension and other functionalities, but is amazing if all you need to do is generate images. Here are my Pro and Contra so far for ComfyUI: Pro: Cons: If you don't know what Hyperparameters, VAEs, Encoders, k-samplers are you will have a hard time doing anything. 💡. Fooocus WebUI: The Fooocus webui has to be the most interesting blend of advanced image diffusion features while at the same time being the a simple toned down interface. Effectively this is the second version of RunDifusion Photo. Apr 4, 2024 · This will create a few different outputs that you can review to see which is best. 5s/it with ComfyUI and around 7it/s with A1111, using an RTX3060 12gb card, does this sound Jul 29, 2023 · Recently, the Stability AI team unveiled SDXL 1. automatic - SD. In the 768 by 1024 test, the average time was 16. When comparing sd-webui-comfyui and stable-diffusion-webui you can also consider the following projects: stable-diffusion-ui - Easiest 1-click way to install and use Stable Diffusion on your computer. 3. 2. You switched accounts on another tab or window. Select the Lora tab. By the way, I don't think ComfyUI is a good name since it's already a famous stable diffusion ui and I thought your extension added that one to auto1111. prompt: A pale blonde girl with a red dress is accessing a new plan of reality, ascending in a higher Dec 16, 2023 · 2 min read. This model has less creativity than Topaz but much more detail. The solution offers an industry leading WebUI, supports terminal use through a CLI, and serves as the foundation for multiple commercial products. It utilizes language models and neural networks to recognize and generate images Basedon textual prompts. I checked on the GitHub and it appears there are a huge number of outstanding issues and not many recent commits. With Easy Diffusion I could crank out 4 to 8 images in just as many seconds, but things took 1 to 2 minutes using the same model in the Automatic1111 version. The big current advantage of ComfyUI over Automatic1111 is it appears to handle VRAM much better. Sytan's SDXL Workflow will load: ComfyUI-Manager. I've been scheduling prompt on hundred of image for animatediff for a long time with giant batch a 1000+ frames. ComfyUI Manager는 ComfyUI 인터페이스를 통해 다른 사용자 지정 노드를 You should check out anapnoe/webui-ux which has similarities with your project. I did try using SDXL 1. Updated: 1/6/2024. Their unified canvas is awesome too. For instance (word:1. Stable-Diffusion-Webui-Civitai-Helper - Stable Diffusion Webui Extension for Civitai, to manage your model much more easily. Click run_nvidia_gpu. It’s a Gradio based interface with When comparing SHARK and ComfyUI you can also consider the following projects: stable-diffusion-webui - Stable Diffusion web UI. Its image compostion capabilities allow you to assign different prompts and weights, even using different models, to specific areas of an image. Comfy speed comparison. Photo realism dialed to 11. Auto1111 gives you tons of tools ready out of the box. The customizable interface and previews further enhance the user experience. Do you use AUTOMATIC11 We're building the MEGAZORD of image generation power. Tech Craft: Fooocus vs ComfyUI for Intel Arc GPUs. stable-diffusion-webui-composable-lora - This extension replaces the built-in LoRA forward procedure. Aug 29, 2023 · Open the extra_model_paths. . Nov 7, 2023 · I consistently get much better results with Automatic1111's webUI compared to ComfyUI even for seemingly identical workflows. Click Refresh if you don’t see your model. Jan 6, 2024 · ComfyUI emerges as a potent tool in the AI art generation landscape, offering unparalleled flexibility and a suite of features that cater to both basic and advanced needs. Fooocus is set apart by automating many steps a user would otherwise do manually. Most (>95%) recent images on CivitAI are from Automatic1111 format, not ComfyUI. So why is the automatic1111 one so much longer? Apr 21, 2024 · 1. Invoke has a far superior ui and I like how it displays a history of all my outputs with the seed and prompt data ready to “rewind” any mistakes I make. 11. Neither is better or worse. ComfyUI avoids all this VRAM and RAM issues easily. ultimate-upscale-for-automatic1111. Is that a… bad idea? I certainly want ComfyUI to run under a venv vs. comfy-image-saver - All the tools you need to save images with their generation metadata on ComfyUI. A clip skip of 2 omits the final layer. multiple LoRas, negative prompting, upscaling), the more Comfy results Automatic1111 is giving me 18-25it/s vs invokes 12-17ish it/s. I've been slowly migrating to comfyui. just installing all those libraries by default. Hello! I just switched from HLKY's fork to AUTOMATIC1111's repo and I found that the results are slightly different. stable-diffusion-webui-amdgpu - Stable Diffusion web UI. AUTO1111 and ComfyUI unite with the Mar 22, 2023 · #stablediffusionart #stablediffusion #stablediffusionai In this Video I have compared Automatic1111 and ComfyUI with img2img Section and Latent Hi-res Fix. Explore the newest features, models, and node updates in ComfyUI and how they can be applied to your digital creations. ComfyUI-Manager. Join our passionate community to stay informed and connected with the latest trends and technologies in the gaming laptop world. Advantages of ComfyUI: ComfyUI VS AUTOMATIC1111. One of the reasons to switch from the stable diffusion webui known as automatic1111 to the newer ComfyUI is the much better memory management. I really recommend. I've noticed comfy be like "Yo, you ran out of ram, let me tile that for you". It offers management functions to install, remove, disable, and enable various custom nodes of ComfyUI. The number of mentions indicates the total number of ultimate-upscale-for-automatic1111. (by invoke-ai) The number of mentions indicates the total number of mentions that we've tracked plus the number of user suggested alternatives. #Rename this to extra_model_paths. To set a clip skip of 1 is to not skip any layers, and to use all 12. lv dg sz sy uj rr em ok qo rf